By Patrick Okigbo III
“Thirteen young Nigerians wrestle with their nation’s promise of brotherhood and what realising it demands from us all”
I have always wondered why official forms in Nigeria ask for one’s state of origin and so rarely for one’s state of residence. I have lived in Abuja for over 15 years. I may live out my natural life here and still be considered a stranger. My children have never lived in Anambra, my ancestral state, except for short holiday visits, but that is where the forms insist they belong. I was born and raised in Enugu, which used to be part of Anambra. Yet, if I sought political office there, I would be reminded where I am from.
Thirteen Athena-Anchoria Junior Fellows wrestle with this and other questions in their essay collection, Though Tribe and Tongue May Differ. Osita Chidoka, Founder and Chancellor of the Athena Centre for Policy and Leadership, invited me to facilitate a conversation with them.
The collection’s title comes from our old, and now restored, national anthem. The line closes with a pledge of brotherhood that always lifts my soul. I wanted to hear what that pledge means to these young Nigerians. They have known Nigeria only as a democracy, and many of our most painful experiences must seem distant to them. Yet they are living in a country that is still struggling to live up to its promise.
Like me, Eunice Olasunkanmi is troubled that government forms are more interested in her father’s ancestry than in where she has lived, studied, or contributed. If ancestry is an unfair reason to exclude her elsewhere, can it be a fair reason to favour her at home? Would those who argue for “indigeneship” in Abuja extend the same to Nigerians who have lived in their own ancestral villages for decades?
Several fellows argue that residency and ancestral heritage can coexist. Living in a traditional community does not confer a claim to its stool. Likewise, a child who grew up in that community should not be denied access to public goods because her grandparents came from elsewhere.
In Imagined Communities, Benedict Anderson argued that a nation exists first in the mind. Most of its members will never meet, yet they conceive of it as a “deep, horizontal comradeship”, and that fraternity is what makes people willing to die for it. How can one be vested in a nation where the comradeship is neither deep nor horizontal?
These questions explain why, since the July 4 weekend, I have been returning to places in the American South where Americans are still working out their nation’s articles of faith.
America has not always lived up to its declarations. Some of the men who proclaimed that “all men are created equal” enslaved other human beings. Its elections have not always been fair. George Washington was badly beaten in a 1755 election. In 1758, he ran in the same county, supplied voters with about 160 gallons of alcohol and won comfortably. He had discovered “stomach infrastructure” before his Nigerian counterparts.
As imperfect as the men were, their declarations gave Americans something to claim as their own. At the March on Washington in 1963, Martin Luther King Jr. described the equality declaration as a promissory note on which America had defaulted in its treatment of its Black citizens. He made his demands because the Founding Fathers made a promise.
Nigeria has made a few promises as well. The restored anthem pledges a nation where truth and justice reign and no man is oppressed. The Constitution declares that “the security and welfare of the people shall be the primary purpose of government.” It calls for “full residence rights for every citizen in all parts of the Federation” and “equality of rights, obligations and opportunities before the law.” On those words, Nigerians can demand that their government end the violent conflicts that have metastasised across the country. State universities should ask applicants for residency certificates, and leave ancestry out of it. Like King, we can call on the note because the Founding Generation made the promises.
The fellows take those words seriously. Abubakar Rashida Bafashi writes about a hepatitis B outreach in Zuru, Kebbi State. He learned that listening to people with respect earned their trust. However, when the promised care fails to follow the campaign promises, the disappointment becomes part of how people experience their country.
Yahaya Abubakar takes the argument further. Those with money leave failing public institutions for private schools and hospitals. When bandits take over the roads, the rich take to the air. When the grid fails, they install solar panels. Even the presidency has installed a solar farm. Albert Hirschman called this Exit. Poor families, on the other hand, accept whatever is available. Citizenship may be the same on paper, but it is hardly Anderson’s comradeship.
When the state continually fails the poor, they learn to cling to their ethnic, religious and family networks. When a Senator’s phone call is the surest way to a job at the Central Bank or the national petroleum company, people learn to fight for their kin to win political office. There is no point in asking Nigerians to put their country first while primordial connections secure the cherished positions.
Our conversation landed on Nigeria’s federal character principle and asked why we still need it. How would we know when it should be retired?
Adaobi Ayogu acknowledges that our forebears instituted it to address fear of domination by the majority ethnic groups, but wonders whether its operation has made ancestry too important. She proposes clear competence requirements, representation drawn only from qualified candidates, and published evidence so that all parties can judge the process.
I leaned on the Flamingos to make a point. Nigeria’s U-17 women’s football team have just won the FIFA World Cup. No one could tell you the ethnic makeup of the team. No one cares. The coaches selected the best players, and they brought pride and joy to their country. Why do we fail to do the same when fielding our economic team?
After seventy-five minutes, we still could not settle the harder questions. How do we help the “educationally disadvantaged” states produce more qualified candidates without pulling down the national average? How long can a state remain disadvantaged before we demand an account of what its governments have done about it?
I enjoyed the conversation because we did not avert our eyes when the questions got uncomfortable. For instance, on residency, even the fellows who agreed that it should confer some permanence after a while could not agree on how many years it should take.
The essays do not dwell only on the difficult. Afodun Muhammad Saheed writes about his friendship with an Igbo trader in Ilorin. Neither had to abandon his identity. But Saheed also recognises the limits of familiarity: public officials must also treat the stranger with whom they share no language, religion or friendship fairly.
As I left the Athena Center and drove into the Abuja after-hours traffic by the Life Camp roundabout, I kept thinking about how any union can work if the parties cannot discuss the terms on which they must live together. Cursing ourselves out on X is not the right way to communicate. The book will be in bookstores this week. Read it. Ask what the fellows think the proposals would mean in your state, your workplace and your children’s school.
As I turned towards the express to head home, I wondered how much longer I needed to live in Abuja before I belonged. I also wondered what I was prepared to concede so that another Nigerian could belong where I come from.
