By Lemmy Ughegbe, Ph.D
There is a difference between disagreeing with a law and disregarding it. The first is the lifeblood of democracy. The second raises hard questions about conviction, civic duty and constitutional order.
Those questions sharpen when the law concerns a national symbol and the dissenters are seeking to govern. The controversy over Peter Obi and the old national anthem is a case in point.
At the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) town hall meeting in Oregun, Lagos, on 12 November 2026, the former Anambra State Governor, alongside Funso Doherty and party supporters, reportedly joined in singing “Arise, O Compatriots” rather than Nigeria’s legally recognised anthem, “Nigeria, We Hail Thee”. Circulated footage shows Obi turning to the audience, fist raised in the NDC salute, as the old anthem rang out.
The symbolism was striking. Whether it was deliberate defiance or simple attachment to familiar words is unclear. But when a leader publicly embraces a symbol the law has replaced, questions follow.
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu signed the National Anthem Act into law on 29 May 2024, restoring the anthem Nigeria sang from independence until 1978. Critics faulted the speed of the process and the priorities of a government presiding over economic hardship.
Those criticisms were legitimate. Nigerians were entitled to question the urgency of an anthem change amid inflation and insecurity. They were equally entitled to prefer the 1978 anthem.
But disagreement does not repeal a law.
The Act establishes
“Nigeria, We Hail Thee” as the national anthem and regulates its performance and the conduct expected when it is played. It does not, however, expressly criminalise singing the former anthem. To accuse Obi and his supporters of committing an offence would therefore be legally inaccurate.
Section 24(a) of the Constitution obliges every citizen to abide by the Constitution and respect its ideals, its institutions, the National Flag, the National Anthem, the National Pledge and legitimate authorities. This is not a demand for blind obedience. Constitutional democracy protects the right to criticise legislation and campaign peacefully for its repeal.
Here, the line between state and government matters. The anthem belongs to Nigeria, not to President Tinubu or the All Progressives Congress. Its authority flows from an Act of the National Assembly, not presidential preference.
That distinction cuts both ways. The opposition should not treat every measure linked to the incumbent as illegitimate. Government supporters should not treat disagreement over an anthem as disloyalty. An anthem should express national identity, not serve as a partisan test of patriotism.
Symbolic dissent is not inherently unpatriotic. But leaders who engage in it owe the public an explanation.
Were Obi and his supporters demanding the return of the old anthem? Were they rejecting the process that produced the 2024 Act? Or were they simply singing words they love? The distinctions matter, because political symbols speak beyond the intentions of those who wield them.
Obi has built his public brand on responsible governance, institutional accountability and respect for rules. Lagos handed him the perfect stage to prove it. He let the moment pass.
His supporters were clearly angry. But anger does not change the law. Whatever their sentiments, the lawful anthem is Nigeria, We Hail Thee, not the one they chose to sing.
A leader in firm control would have ascended the podium, calmed the crowd and reminded them that those who seek to change a law must first respect it. That single act would have marked him out as a statesman.
Instead, Obi turned to his supporters smiling, fist aloft, and let the old anthem ring. He followed the crowd when he should have led it.
It was a big own goal, scored by Obi and his supporters alike.
None of this means opposition politicians must endorse every government decision. It simply demands clarity between advocating lawful change and symbolically challenging an existing law.
The standard must apply across the divide. Those who demand constitutional obedience must equally condemn disobedience of court orders, interference with institutions and every other assault on the rule of law, whoever holds power.
There is another dimension that must not be drowned out by the anthem row. Suspected thugs reportedly disrupted the meeting, attacking participants and damaging property. That violence poses a graver threat to democracy than any disagreement over lyrics.
The authorities must investigate impartially, identify those responsible and protect the right of every party to organise peacefully. Respect for constitutional order cannot be selective. A government cannot ask citizens to honour national symbols while failing to protect their constitutional freedoms.
So what does patriotism require? Is loyalty measured by the anthem one sings or by fidelity to the values it represents? Can a citizen reject the current form of a national symbol and still love the country?
The law has settled Nigeria’s anthem. Citizens remain free to debate it and pursue its reversal through democratic means. But political leaders must remember that their conduct carries weight far beyond the excitement of a partisan gathering.
The true test of patriotism is neither blind obedience nor defiance for its own sake. It is fidelity to constitutional democracy, where laws command respect, dissent enjoys protection and those who seek to govern are ready to explain their actions.
Dr Lemmy Ughegbe, FIMC, CMC
Email: lemmyughegbeofficial@gmail.com
WhatsApp ONLY: +2348069716645
