A legal practitioner, Yakubu Eleto Esq., has called on Hon. Timehin Adelegbe and other stakeholders in the All Progressives Congress (APC) primary election dispute in Owo/Ose Federal Constituency of Ondo State to respect the judicial process ahead of the Supreme Court’s determination of the matter.
Eleto urged the parties to refrain from making comments capable of prejudicing public perception of the case, stressing that disputes already before the courts should be allowed to run their full course without unnecessary media interventions.
Speaking on the controversy surrounding the APC primary election, the lawyer said the integrity of the judiciary must be protected, particularly when a matter is awaiting determination by the nation’s apex court.
According to him, public commentary on pending litigation should be guided by restraint and respect for the independence of the judiciary.
“I have followed this matter with keen interest for one fundamental reason: the proper treatment of the directive issued by the APC to its various primary election committees across the country, instructing them not to make final declarations of winners but to reserve that responsibility for the Party’s National Headquarters,” he said.
Eleto noted that the directive had generated legal and political discussions at the time but maintained that the courts should be given the opportunity to determine the issues arising from the dispute.
He said, “At the time, this directive attracted considerable criticism from legal minds, who questioned its legality and consistency with the Party’s own electoral guidelines. Nevertheless, the courts have had the opportunity to examine the issues arising from the dispute, and we must allow the judicial process to run its full course”.
The lawyer observed that the decisions of the lower courts had addressed important questions relating to the parties involved in the case, adding that the Supreme Court’s final pronouncement remained crucial to resolving the dispute.
“Thus far, the decisions of the two lower courts have addressed important questions surrounding the parties before the Court, including why the APC was considered the only necessary party to be sued in respect of the claims presented. However, notwithstanding the decisions already delivered, we must await the final pronouncement of the Supreme Court,” he stated.
Eleto said public statements surrounding the dispute should not be allowed to overshadow the legal issues before the court, particularly with the appeal instituted by Adelegbe approaching its hearing.
He expressed confidence in the capacity of the Supreme Court justices to examine the arguments presented by the parties and deliver their decision in accordance with the law.
“In my considered view, this is entirely unnecessary. The Justices of the Supreme Court are eminently equipped to consider and determine the appeal objectively, without fear or favour. Indeed, their judicial records speak for themselves,” he said.
The legal practitioner also commented on the position of Hon. Ghani Rotimi Arobo, saying his decision not to make public statements on the matter should be viewed within the context of the pending appeal and respect for judicial proceedings.
Eleto further drew attention to the issues surrounding the declaration of candidates in the disputed APC primary election, particularly the findings of the lower courts concerning the evidence presented in support of Adelegbe’s claim to the party’s ticket.
He said the court proceedings had raised questions about the documentary evidence relied upon by the parties to establish the outcome of the primary election.
According to him, the issues relating to the conduct of the primary, the party’s nomination procedures and the relevant electoral guidelines remain matters for judicial determination.
He also stressed the importance of compliance with the provisions of the Electoral Act and the internal regulations of political parties in the conduct of primary elections.
“The law does not permit the substitution of genuine electoral processes with manufactured outcomes. It is encouraging that courts are increasingly insisting on compliance with the law and the established procedures governing party nominations and political impunity must not be allowed to thrive without accountability,” Eleto said.
The lawyer urged all parties involved in the dispute to exercise restraint and avoid statements that could be interpreted as attempts to influence public opinion while the appeal remained pending.
He also expressed confidence in the independence of the Supreme Court, urging political stakeholders to refrain from making unverified claims about the proceedings or anticipated outcome of the appeal.
“We have absolute confidence in the independence, integrity and institutional dignity of the Supreme Court,” he said.
Eleto advised Adelegbe to allow the appeal he instituted to proceed without unnecessary public controversy, adding that all parties should be prepared to abide by the court’s eventual decision.
“Hon. Adelegbe should have faith in the appeal he personally instituted. He must be prepared to accept whatever outcome the Court ultimately reaches. Whether he wins or loses, the judicial process must be allowed to take its course. The Supreme Court must be permitted to discharge its constitutional responsibility without intimidation, external pressure or media manipulation,” he added.
